“I’d Rather Be Naughty Than Nice,” the show also alternates between Tina Burner’s signature mixes and live arrangements of pop and holiday standards orchestrated by Broadway’s Blake Allen at Crown & Anchor in Provincetown.

After years of being the Stepford Christmas Wife, Ms. Claus takes a hard candy look at her relationship with the infamous Kristopher Kringle. We finally get the back story of the North Pole’s first lady, how she met her husband, and how things aren’t always a Winter Wonderland. As the Christmas cookie starts to crumble, Ms. Claus is left with the question: would she rather be naughty than nice?